Real-world cases

Case study: a buyer claims frozen seafood is underweight

The buyer reweighs and finds the net weight lower than declared because of glazing. How to avoid disputes over glazing percentages.

Mr. Dan
Mr. Dan10+ years of export experience

This is a composite, illustrative case.

What happened

A frozen seafood exporter's buyer thawed the product to check it and concluded that the actual net weight was lower than labelled, because there was more glaze than agreed. The buyer demanded compensation for the difference.

The usual causes

  • The contract didn't specify the glazing percentage or how net weight is determined.
  • Inconsistent glazing control at the plant.
  • The buyer's thawing and weighing method differed from the plant's.

How it was handled

  • Propose an independent survey using the agreed method or a recognised international method.
  • Compare with the plant's inspection records.
  • Negotiate compensation if the product really was short.

Prevention

  • The contract should specify net weight after thawing, the glazing percentage and the method of determination.
  • Control the glazing process and keep test results for every lot.
  • Label the correct net weight under the market's rules.
  • Some markets treat incorrect net weight declarations very seriously, as commercial fraud.