Contracts

Penalties, damages and claims

What penalty is reasonable, how long the claim period should be and what evidence a claim needs: the clauses that decide how much you can lose when things go wrong.

Mr. Dan
Mr. Dan10+ years of export experience

When everything goes smoothly, nobody rereads the penalty clause. But when there's a problem, it decides who loses how much.

Penalties

  • The contract should set specific penalties for common breaches: late delivery, short delivery, late payment.
  • Example late-delivery penalty: 0.5% of the value of the late lot per week of delay, capped at 5%. Always have a cap.
  • Under Vietnam's Commercial Law, penalties for breach of a commercial contract may not exceed 8% of the value of the breached obligation, with some exceptions. If the contract uses another country's law, the rules may differ.
  • Be careful with buyers' templates that have high, uncapped or one-sided penalties.

Damages

Damages differ from penalties: actual loss must be proven. Limit the seller's liability, for example not exceeding the contract value and excluding indirect losses such as lost profits or claims from the buyer's own customers.

Claims

  • Claim period: for quantity, usually short, e.g. 15–30 days after arrival; for quality, depending on the goods, e.g. 30–60 days. After that, the seller is not liable.
  • Claim documents: a written claim, a survey certificate from an independent body, photos and reports. Don't accept a claim made only by email with a few photos.
  • The goods under claim must be kept as they are so the seller can send someone to inspect.
  • Settlement options: a discount, replacement, cash compensation or a credit against the next order.

In practice

Most claims are settled by negotiation. Clear clauses give both sides the same "rules of the game", speed up negotiation and protect the long-term relationship.